Regardless, the fact that the study only analyzed football and basketball leaves a lot of other high school athletes out of the analysis. I would be more interested in this analysis if all sports including wrestling were considered in the study.
Vince, I personally believe that if wrestling were analyzed it would even further destroy the argument that KSHSAA is causing our student/athletes to be left behind. As it is, using the sports that were included, I think we can put that argument to rest for the foreseeable future.
sportsfan02, I had a day off yesterday and I had to see if this was true. I felt it would not take me that much time to do this analysis since there are only five Big 12 teams. I felt that the KSHSAA using only football and basketball in their analysis could be self serving to a position that everything is fine and change is not needed. I decided to see how this same analysis would come out just for the sport that I am mainly interested in having changes to improve the situation for our athletes and that sport is wrestling. I applied the same numbers in population for the per 100,000 residents and the 14 to 17 year old residents to the 2008-2009 Big 12 wrestling rosters.
CONCLUSION OF RESULTS: KANSAS DOES NOT DO AS WELL IN WRESTLING PER CAPITA IN BIG 12 ATHLETES IN COMPARATIVE STATES AS IT EVIDENTLY DOES IN FOOTBALL AND BASKETBALL. IN WRESTLING KANSAS COMES IN 5TH OF 7 IN BOTH CATEGORIES OF PER 100,000 STATE RESIDENTS AND PER 10,000 OF 14-17 YR OLD PER 10,000 IN COMPARISON TO 2ND IN BOTH CATEGORIES IN FOOTBALL AND BASKETBALL.
Here are the numbers for the 2008-2009 Big 12
Wrestling rosters per state:
OK-23
MO-18
IA-15
NE-8
KS-7
TX-6
CO-4
Using the population numbers in the report here is how
Wrestling turns out per 100,000 state residents:
OK-.63
IA-.50
NE-.45
MO-.30
KS-.25
CO-.08
TX-.02
Using the 14-17 year old population numbers in the report here is how
Wrestling turns out per 100,000 state residents:
OK-1.13
IA-0.89
NE-0.78
MO-0.53
KS-0.44
CO-0.15
TX-0.04
So I could use my wrestling analysis of Big 12 wrestlers as support to my position that KSHSAA policies need to be changed to help our high school wrestlers improve their chances to become college wrestlers. Would I be completely fair in doing so? Probably not, since it only is analyzing the Big 12 and the fact that Kansas has no Big 12 team and Oklahoma has two and MO, NE, IA have one certainly gives each state an advantage over Kansas in this analysis. All those states fall ahead of Kansas in this wrestling analysis.
However, using the same reasoning I do not think it is correct for the KSHSAA to use only football and basketball in the Big 12 to support a position that their current policies are fine and do not need changing.One thing that I found to be disappointing in going over the rosters of the Big 12 wrestling teams is that the University of Missouri only had one Kansas wrestler on the squad in the 2008-2009 year. We border Missouri and you would think we should get more Kansas recruits on their squad.