Several ways to look at it and the LPA chose this perspective. Whether you agree/believe is beside the point; it is what it is. The numbers, based on the comparison used by the LPA don't lie. As I pointed out in one of my earlier posts on this subjecgt, having two Big 12 football schools in a state our size will give us an advantage in this comparison...Does it prove that the KSHSAA is a positive in HS FB & BB? Would be hard to argue they are; at the least one could argue no harm is being done in those sports...
Greg Mann:
The numbers in the study may not lie but they can mislead a person to an incorrect conclusion. If the basis of a study is too narrow and gives some subjects of the study advantages over other subjects of the study then the study and its conclusions are not revelant. If you believe the report gives Kansas an advantage since its has two Big 12 schools with our lower population base than how can you even draw the conclusion from the report that?
at the least one could argue no harm is being done in those sports
And I am not saying that KSHSAA policies are harming us in producing Division I athletes in football and/or basketball. I am just saying that conclusion cannot be reached from this particular study and information.I really try to question studies and financial numbers when they are presented to me. I want my children to do the same. People try to sell you things all the time and you need to critically question the material being presented to you otherwise you could end up buying the Brooklyn Bridge or an elevator pass at a school that doesn't have an elevator. I could set up a study that would compare how the 6A schools measure against the 3-2-1A schools in producing varsity high school wrestlers. The 3-2-1A schools would definitely come out better per capita because they are filling the same 14 number of spots on the team with a lot less students in their schools than the 6-A schools. This would be a meaningless study. You certainly could not jump to the conclusion that 3-2-1A schools are doing better at producing varsity wrestlers than 6-A schools based on this type of study.
The fact that the study shows there are 24,326,974 people in Texas and only four Big 12 schools for an average of 6,081,474 in state residents per Big 12 school vs. 2,802,134 in Kansas with 2 Big 12 schools for an average of only 1,401,067 in state residents per Big 12 school demonstrates to me that this study is not a fair basis of comparsion.
This study does not in any way convince me that Kansas high schools are per capita ahead of Texas high schools in producing Division I football and/or basketball players. There may be such a study but this is not it. We are just not comparing apples to apples in this study. It is way too narrow and the sample is not large enough to draw any meaningful conclusions. My common sense tells me that Kansas would probably be behind Texas per capita in producing Division I football players but I really could be incorrect about that on a per capita basis. Perhaps sportsfan02 will be able to provide us the data that shows us that Kansas is in fact ahead of Texas in producing Division I football players per capita.