I think you're right about Jon Trenge. I thought there was a guy from Hofstra in the past few years though who had nearly the same thing, but I couldn't find any info on the web.

I've posted a link to his bio and a video preview of a documentary covering Trenge's senior year. I'd never even heard of this film but now I'm gonna have to buy it for Walker and Texas Ranger for Christmas.
Jon Trenge Bio

Veritas Jon Trenge Wrestling Documentary Preview

[Linked Image from media1.tenor.com]