Grandpa,
If one wrestler, through the scoring criteria posted, has a higher point total he is deemed the winner. When a "winner" is determined, you are by definition down to a two way tie. A two way tie can "always" be broken by a head-to-head comparison. The scoring criteria called out is not intended to be used to place the wrestlers 1,2,3...it is intended to be used only to "break the tie".
Only if you are still left with a three way tie when utilizing the scoring criteria will the entire bracket need to wrestled again.
