I"ve softened my stance on this issue somewhat. I think if a freshman, who still qualifies for 14u age group, places at HS state, my personal recommendation would be for him to wrestle the HS division. I'd sure have a talk with him, to see what we thought was best for his improvement. However, there are instances where a 14u kid has had a rough road in HS, whether he qualified for HS state or not, and needs a "break" to wrestle kids more his age and maturity level.