Tournament and dual results have got to be posted, otherwise I have no idea what is going on. That would be the most helpful. Sadly, most local papers require on-line fees anymore making it impossible to find some tournament results and so I, like you, am totally dependant on the information supplied by the wrestling community on this forum.
Understandably, some coaches are very guarded with their information and prefer to keep some of their athletes from acquiring a bullseye, so they leave it up to ranking guy.
There is no set formula on how to to this. Ballots could be sent out and sent back or it could be done electronically, but since wrestling isn't televised and information isn't always posted right away, many coaches aren't sure where exactly to put kids that they haven't seen in person. What I do is put together a preseason rankings and make it available at the KWCA clinic in the fall and encourage coaches to fill that out and mail it back to me. I then do a preseason poll, that is updated as I recieve information throughout the season. We are the only sport that does this which makes it very difficult. Could you imagine the KBCA putting together a top six list of the best point guards in Kansas. It would be awfully subjective as is the wrestling rankings when you haven't seen some kids go head to head.
The best thing to do is to post information on the wrestlers so that i can see the results and if some kid was up 14-0 and then defensivly pinned himself, that is helpful to know as well.
Also, to any coaches that have e-mailed me from time to time say "rank this kid or that kid" please continue to do so, the rest of you, POST RESULTS